Start by deciding what you want on the board. A soft spruce-wrapped cheese, a bright goat cheese, and a firm cheese made from pasture milk each do a different job. These cheeses are still made by American producers, and…

Items8The creator’s order
  1. 1Harbison by Jasper Hill FarmHarbison by Jasper Hill FarmLift the top rind and spoon the soft middle straight from the little wheel. Jasper Hill wraps this Vermont cow’s-milk cheese in spruce bark, which gives its sweet, creamy paste a woodsy edge. Pick it when you want one cheese that can anchor the board with little more than bread and something tart.0
  2. 2Rogue River Blue by Rogue CreameryRogue River Blue by Rogue CreameryThe Oregon creamery makes this blue seasonally, then wraps the aged wheels in Syrah grape leaves soaked in pear spirits. Look for it when you want a blue with a fruit-and-earth contrast, and ask ahead about the current release. A small wedge beside slices of pear is enough to show what the wrapping…0
  3. 3Pleasant Ridge Reserve by Uplands CheesePleasant Ridge Reserve by Uplands CheeseUplands makes this Wisconsin Alpine-style cheese while the herd is on fresh pasture. The firm paste has enough nutty depth to serve in thin slices and will hold its own beside a tart apple. Ask a cheesemonger whether the wedge is standard or extra-aged if you want a gentler or more concentrated…0
  4. 4Humboldt Fog by Cypress GroveHumboldt Fog by Cypress GroveThe narrow stripe through this California goat cheese is edible vegetable ash. Try the firmer, brighter center and the softer cream line by the rind in the same bite. Choose a more mature wedge if you want a broader cream line and stronger flavor.0
  5. 5Green Hill by Sweet Grass DairyGreen Hill by Sweet Grass DairyGreen Hill is a silky double-cream cow’s-milk cheese from Georgia with a subtle mushroom note. It is an easy choice when you want the soft round on the board to feel rich but not dominate the food beside it. Serve a wedge with buttered toast or a little tart fruit.0
  6. 6Prairie Breeze by Milton CreameryPrairie Breeze by Milton CreameryThis Iowa cheddar-style cheese is sweet and tangy with a little crystalline crunch. It can move from a snack board to a grilled cheese without losing its flavor. Buy it when you want something familiar enough for a mixed crowd with just enough texture to make people ask what it is.0
  7. 7Appalachian by Meadow Creek DairyAppalachian by Meadow Creek DairyMeadow Creek’s original cheese comes from a mountain dairy in southwest Virginia. The white rind frames a velvety paste that can taste buttery and earthy, with brighter lemon notes in a younger wedge. It suits a board where you want a milder cheese with more to notice than its first soft bite.0
  8. 8Barely Buzzed by Beehive CheeseBarely Buzzed by Beehive CheeseEspresso and lavender form the dark rub on this cow’s-milk cheddar. Try a bite with a little rind and another from the middle to see how much of the roasted flavor comes from the outside. It’s the pick for a board that already has a plain cheddar and needs a more unusual second wedge.0