Between 1989 and 1999, Walt Disney Feature Animation took hand-drawn movies from Ariel’s Broadway-style songs to Tarzan’s sweeping digital jungle. This ranking revisits all ten films with adult eyes, weighing how well…

Items10The creator’s order
  1. 1Beauty and the Beast (1991)Beauty and the Beast (1991)8.0IMDbReleased Oct 22, 1991The first animated film nominated for the Best Picture Oscar, and the one where every piece fits. Howard Ashman and Alan Menken wrote it like a stage score: "Belle" sets up a whole town in one number, and Gaston is a villain built from charm, which makes him more unsettling to an adult than to a…0
  2. 2The Lion King (1994)The Lion King (1994)8.5IMDbReleased Jun 15, 1994The Renaissance at its most cinematic. Hans Zimmer’s score and the opening chorus give the sunrise a scale nothing else here matches, while Elton John and Tim Rice supply the songs. Jeremy Irons gives Scar a weary theatrical contempt that makes “Be Prepared” a standout. The computer-generated…0
  3. 3Aladdin (1992)Aladdin (1992)8.0IMDbReleased Nov 25, 1992Robin Williams’s Genie is the fastest, funniest performance in these films. Supervising animator Eric Goldberg borrowed Al Hirschfeld’s flowing lines for a character who can turn a change of voice into a whole new shape. Howard Ashman wrote lyrics for songs including “Friend Like Me.” Tim Rice…0
  4. 4The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996)The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996)7.0IMDbReleased Jun 21, 1996Disney’s darkest film of the era gains ground on an adult rewatch. Tony Jay’s Judge Frollo turns his obsession with Esmeralda into a claim of moral duty, and “Hellfire” makes that hypocrisy unsettling even without the visuals. Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz put the scale of an opera into “The…0
  5. 5The Little Mermaid (1989)The Little Mermaid (1989)7.6IMDbReleased Nov 17, 1989Where the Renaissance started. Howard Ashman and Alan Menken build the film around its songs. “Part of Your World” gives Ariel’s longing a shape, and the Oscar-winning “Under the Sea” turns Sebastian’s sales pitch into a spectacle. Pat Carroll’s Ursula has a stage diva’s timing in “Poor Unfortunate…0
  6. 6Mulan (1998)Mulan (1998)7.7IMDbReleased Jun 18, 1998The best action film of the era gives its heroine a battle she has to win with her head. The avalanche is the late Renaissance’s most thrilling set piece, and “I’ll Make a Man Out of You,” sung by Donny Osmond for Captain Li Shang, makes a training montage into one of its sharpest numbers. Ming-Na…0
  7. 7Tarzan (1999)Tarzan (1999)7.3IMDbReleased Jun 17, 1999The last film of the era is its most kinetic. Disney’s Deep Canvas technique gave the animated jungle enough depth for the camera to follow Tarzan as he surfs the branches. Most of Phil Collins’s songs play over the action. The exception that matters is “You’ll Be in My Heart,” the Oscar-winning…0
  8. 8Hercules (1997)Hercules (1997)7.3IMDbReleased Jun 13, 1997The funniest film of the era is also its most stylized. Gerald Scarfe’s sharp, swirling designs give the gods and monsters a look unlike anything else here, and the Muses tell the story in gospel-inflected numbers. James Woods plays Hades with a salesman’s patter, and Susan Egan’s Meg gets some of…0
  9. 9The Rescuers Down Under (1990)The Rescuers Down Under (1990)6.8IMDbReleased Nov 16, 1990The overlooked one, and a surprise on a rewatch. With no musical numbers, the flight on Marahute lets the Australian outback do the talking. The animators still drew by hand, but Disney and Pixar’s CAPS system replaced hand-painted cels with digital ink, paint, and compositing for the whole…0
  10. 10Pocahontas (1995)Pocahontas (1995)6.7IMDbReleased Jun 16, 1995The era’s most striking landscapes are in its hardest film to defend. The tall pines and broad Virginia horizons give the characters an unusually bold setting. “Colors of the Wind,” by Alan Menken and Stephen Schwartz, won the Oscar for Best Original Song, and Menken’s score won too. The film turns…0