Start with two questions about any government. Who chooses the people who run it, and who can ask them to leave? The examples here show how the answers change from Westminster to Washington and from Berlin to Pretoria.…

Items8The creator’s order
  1. 1United KingdomUnited KingdomParliamentary constitutional monarchy. Voters elect members of the House of Commons, and the government needs the Commons’ confidence to govern. A government that loses a confidence vote traditionally resigns or asks for Parliament to be dissolved so voters can elect a new Commons. Start here to…0
  2. 2United StatesUnited StatesPresidential republic. The president is chosen separately from Congress through the Electoral College and serves a four-year term. The House can impeach, and removal follows if two-thirds of senators present convict. A president and Congress can therefore remain in office while disagreeing on…0
  3. 3GermanyGermanyParliamentary republic. The Bundestag elects the federal chancellor on a proposal from the federal president. To remove the chancellor by a no-confidence vote, the Bundestag must elect a successor by a majority of its members. Germany shows how a parliament can replace a government while ensuring…0
  4. 4FranceFranceSemi-presidential republic. Voters choose the president directly, and the president appoints the prime minister. The government answers to Parliament and must resign if the National Assembly adopts a motion of censure. The two executive offices can be held by people from opposing political camps,…0
  5. 5BrazilBrazilPresidential republic with a direct election. The president and vice president run together, and a second round follows if no candidate wins an absolute majority of valid votes. The president heads the executive independently of congressional confidence. Removal for an impeachable offense follows…0
  6. 6IndiaIndiaParliamentary republic. The president appoints the prime minister and appoints the other ministers on the prime minister’s advice. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, the elected lower house. This example shows why the formal act of appointment and the power that…0
  7. 7South AfricaSouth AfricaAssembly-elected executive presidency. The National Assembly elects a president from among its members, who then leaves the Assembly seat. The president is both head of state and head of the national executive. An Assembly majority can pass a no-confidence motion against the president, requiring…0
  8. 8SwitzerlandSwitzerlandCollegial executive. The Federal Assembly elects seven members of the Federal Council for four-year terms. One serves as president of the Confederation for a year, while the council continues to govern collectively. Switzerland shows how a legislature can choose an executive without concentrating…0