If you’re looking for the version you remember from childhood, start with the maker and the packaging. A Coleco doll with its adoption papers tells a different story from a later Cabbage Patch Kid. The same goes for a…

Items9The creator’s order
  1. 1Cabbage Patch KidsCabbage Patch KidsColeco’s Cabbage Patch Kids were the hard-to-find holiday dolls of 1983. Their soft bodies and molded heads made them different from the earlier cloth dolls, but they kept the idea that you were adopting a child with a name of its own. Look for a Coleco box and the adoption papers if you want the…0
  2. 2Rubik's CubeRubik's CubeIdeal put Rubik’s Cube in stores in 1980, and the puzzle’s worldwide sales reached 100 million within two years. The cube is still made, so the box tells you more about the era than the six colors do. If you want an early U.S. example, look for Ideal branding on the original packaging and compare…0
  3. 3My Little Pony (1982 toyline)My Little Pony (1982 toyline)Start with the first Hasbro ponies if you want the figures that established the line in the early ’80s. Butterscotch’s butterflies and Cotton Candy’s spots are good clues for identifying a loose pony, although those designs also returned in anniversary releases. Check the underside and packaging…0
  4. 4Transformers: Generation 1Transformers: Generation 1Hasbro’s 1984 Transformers turned vehicles into characters with help from a comic, a cartoon, and the biographies printed on their boxes. If you’re looking for an early Optimus Prime, ask to see the trailer and smaller pieces as well as the cab. Generation 1 has been reissued, so compare the exact…0
  5. 5Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles action figuresTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles action figuresThe original Playmates action figures put the four Turtles on toy shelves in 1988. The line was the top seller among U.S. action figures by 1990. If you’re looking for an early Leonardo or Donatello, collectors distinguish the soft-headed variants from the versions with harder heads. Check the…0
  6. 6POG Classics Milk CapsPOG Classics Milk CapsPlayers used a heavier slammer to flip a stack of cardboard caps. Under the World POG Federation rules, you kept any caps that flipped face down. The federation’s Classics designs give you a defined group to collect out of a fad with countless designs. Check the marks on the backs of loose caps and…0
  7. 7Tickle Me ElmoTickle Me ElmoTyco’s laughing plush Elmo set off toy shortages in the 1996 holiday season. If that’s the version you remember, look for the Tyco Preschool name on its packaging and compare the toy with the first version. Later Elmos added different motions or used new boxes. With a loose one, check whether the…0
  8. 8TamagotchiTamagotchiBandai’s little egg-shaped pet first appeared in Japan in 1996 and reached North America in 1997. Its screen gave you a pet that needed feeding and cleaning even when you had other things to do. Bandai reissued the old programming in new shells, so a box that says Original Tamagotchi can still be…0
  9. 9Tiger Electronics FurbyTiger Electronics FurbyTiger Electronics’ Furby became a holiday sensation in 1998. The original made the most of a moving face and a string of Furbish phrases, gradually mixing in preprogrammed English. Look for the Tiger markings and original packaging if you’re dating one. For a loose Furby you want to switch on, ask…0