If the Old Fashioned is your usual order, start with a Manhattan or a Sazerac for a drink that still puts rye up front. Bourbon takes well to a heap of crushed ice and mint, while Scotch can go smoky, fruity, or…
Items9The creator’s order
- 1
Manhattan (cocktail)Start here if you like the way an Old Fashioned lets the whiskey speak. Stir rye with sweet red vermouth and a dash of Angostura, then strain it into a cold glass. The vermouth does the sweetening and gives you an herbal finish that plain sugar can't.0
- 2
SazeracGive the chilled glass an Herbsaint rinse and pour away the excess. That thin coat lends an anise scent to the rye, sugar and Peychaud's bitters. A lemon twist lifts the aroma. Pick this when you want the concentration of an Old Fashioned with a more fragrant first sip.0
- 3
Vieux Carré (cocktail)Split the base between rye and cognac, then add sweet vermouth, Bénédictine and bitters. The brandy rounds out the rye, while a little Bénédictine brings in a layer of herbs. This is the richer pour to try when a Manhattan feels a little too straight down the middle.0
- 4
Mint julepGo for a julep when you want bourbon to taste cold and fresh. Press the mint gently with sugar and water, pack the cup with cracked ice and stir in the bourbon until the cup frosts. The mint sprig puts the fragrance right where you take the first sip.0
- 5
Rob Roy (cocktail)If you have blended Scotch and a bottle of sweet vermouth, you already have the makings of a Rob Roy. Add aromatic bitters and stir it like a Manhattan. Start with a gently flavored blend if you want to taste the vermouth as clearly as the whisky.0
- 6
Penicillin (cocktail)Save the peaty Scotch for the very top. Shake blended Scotch, lemon, honey and ginger for the base, then float a little smoky Islay whisky over it. You get the smoke as you raise the glass and the ginger as you drink, without needing to build the whole cocktail around a heavily peated bottle.0
- 7
Blood and Sand (cocktail)Reach for this when you'd rather have fruit than smoke. Orange juice and cherry liqueur lighten up the Scotch, while sweet vermouth links the fruit to the whisky. Try a Scotch-forward recipe if you want a brighter drink that still tastes like whisky after the first sip.0
- 8
Irish coffeeFor the warm option, stir Irish whiskey and sugar into hot coffee and pour cold cream over the back of a spoon so it floats. Sip the hot coffee through that cool top layer. The temperature difference is half the pleasure, so leave the cream where it lands.0
- 9
Scotch and sodaFor a cold, fizzy drink with no syrup or liqueur, pour Scotch over ice and top it with plain soda water. Keep it short with a splash of soda, or add more to taste in a tall glass for a lighter drink.0