Tickle Me Elmo
Tyco’s laughing plush Elmo set off toy shortages in the 1996 holiday season. If that’s the version you remember, look for the Tyco Preschool name on its packaging and compare the toy with the first version. Later Elmos added different motions or used new boxes. With a loose one, check whether the battery compartment is clean and the laugh still works.
More about Tickle Me Elmo