Andy Guitar
10 Day Guitar Starter Course
The best answer to "I'm not sure I'll stick with this." Andy Crowley's free challenge teaches a new song each day for ten days, starting with two chords, with fretboard diagrams and strumming patterns on screen as you go. Taking longer than ten days is fine: the point is that you are playing recognizable music in the first week, which is what keeps a nervous adult picking the guitar back up. It is built around acoustic guitar; the site has a separate beginner electric course for anyone plugged in. Once it clicks, move on to a fuller course such as JustinGuitar or Andy's own beginner pathway.
More about Andy Guitar