Copyright © 2026 OyList. All Rights Reserved.
Share
Items12
1
Mare of Easttown (2021)
8.4/10on IMDb
First aired
Kate Winslet’s Mare has to investigate a murder in a Pennsylvania town where she already knows the people she’s questioning. That familiarity gives the show some of its best misdirection: you start trusting the same people Mare does. The reveal still has time to show what the truth costs the people left behind, which is why this takes the top spot.
More about Mare of Easttown2
Broadchurch (2013)
8.3/10on IMDb
First aired
Broadchurch, Season 1
Two detectives investigate the death of a boy in a small English seaside town. Olivia Colman’s Ellie Miller knows the people David Tennant’s Alec Hardy sees as suspects, and the tension between them makes every interview count. The first season answers who killed the boy and gives the people closest to him room to react.
More about Broadchurch3
Unforgotten (2015)
8.4/10on IMDb
First aired
Unforgotten, Season 2
A body found in a suitcase pulls Cassie Stuart and Sunny Khan into a cold case involving people who seem to have little in common. Give the separate stories time to come together. The finale makes sense of those connections and leaves the detectives with a harder question than who did it.
More about Unforgotten4
And Then There Were None (2015)
7.8/10on IMDb
First aired
Ten strangers on an island, a dwindling suspect list, and nowhere to go. The 2015 British adaptation makes every awkward meal and closed door feel like a clue. It’s an especially good pick if you want a classic Agatha Christie setup with a genuinely unnerving atmosphere and a solution you can argue about afterward.
More about And Then There Were None5
Magpie Murders (2022)
7.5/10on IMDb
First aired
An editor receives a mystery manuscript with its last chapter missing. Then the novelist who wrote it is found dead. You get a contemporary murder and the fictional case the author left unfinished. The pleasure is seeing the two solutions click into place together, especially if you like comparing what people put into a story with what they leave out.
More about Magpie Murders6
True Detective (2014)
8.8/10on IMDb
First aired
True Detective, Season 1
Two Louisiana detectives revisit a murder across a pair of timelines. The strange crime scenes will get you through the door, but the friction between Rust and Marty is what makes the slower stretches work. The main case closes and the partnership gets a memorable final scene, with some of the wider conspiracy left open.
More about True Detective7
Sharp Objects (2018)
8.0/10on IMDb
First aired
A reporter returns to her Missouri hometown to cover a girl’s murder and another girl’s disappearance. The investigation gets under your skin because so many of the people she needs to talk to already know exactly how to get to her. It’s a heavy, deliberately paced watch with an ending that snaps into focus fast. Stay through the credits of the final episode.
More about Sharp Objects8
The Sinner (2017)
7.8/10on IMDb
First aired
The Sinner, Season 1
Cora kills a man on a crowded beach. The mystery is why she did it, and her own account can only take Detective Harry Ambrose so far. The last episodes make sense of reactions that seemed baffling at the start, and the finale gives Cora a chance to live with what she learns.
More about The Sinner9
Deadloch (2023)
7.5/10on IMDb
First aired
Deadloch, Season 1
A murder in a small Tasmanian town pairs a local detective with a wildly different investigator from out of town. The clash is funny enough to carry the early interviews, and the season keeps finding reasons to take its sprawling cast of suspects seriously. The case gets a proper answer even if the comedy is what brings you in.
More about Deadloch10
The Afterparty (2022)
7.3/10on IMDb
First aired
The Afterparty, Season 1
A high school reunion ends with a murder, and the main suspects retell the night in their own genre. The game is spotting what survives the switch from one person’s story to the next. There’s real clue work underneath the jokes, so the answer feels worth trying to beat the show to.
More about The Afterparty11
Only Murders in the Building (2021)
8.0/10on IMDb
First aired
Only Murders in the Building, Season 1
Three neighbors start a true-crime podcast about a death in their own apartment building. The fun is watching them turn people they barely know into suspects, then have to rethink what they thought they knew. The finale solves the case before teeing up a new one, so there’s a reason to keep watching and a satisfying place to stop.
More about Only Murders in the Building12
The Residence (2025)
7.7/10on IMDb
First aired
A state dinner leaves a body in the White House and detective Cordelia Cupp with more people to interview than anyone wants to admit were in the building. Settle in if you like reconstructing who went where and when. The show takes its time, then gives Cupp a chance to lay out how the whole messy evening fits together.
More about The Residence