Copyright © 2026 OyList. All Rights Reserved.
Share
Items24
1
12 Angry Men (1957)
9.0/10on IMDb
Released
The argument starts before the credits: is Juror 8 a hero of reasonable doubt, or simply the most persuasive man in the room? Sidney Lumet keeps almost the whole story inside one jury room, and Henry Fonda's calm refusal to vote guilty without a discussion turns a murder trial into a study of prejudice, impatience and how groups change their minds. It is the ideal opener for a new club, because everyone will have a view on which juror they would have been.
More about 12 Angry Men2
Two Days, One Night (2014)
7.3/10on IMDb
Released
Would you give up a 1,000-euro bonus so a colleague could keep her job? That is the whole film, and it is plenty. Marion Cotillard's Sandra, returning to the factory after depression, spends one weekend visiting the coworkers who voted against her before a second, secret ballot on Monday morning. The Dardenne brothers refuse to make anyone a villain: each doorstep conversation brings its own reasons, and a group soon finds itself defending people it expected to judge.
More about Two Days, One Night3
Force Majeure (2014)
7.2/10on IMDb
Released
A father's split-second reaction to an apparent avalanche at a resort in the French Alps becomes the question that eats his family's ski vacation: can you hold someone responsible for an instinct? Ruben Östlund plays it as a deadpan comedy of embarrassment, which makes the debate easy to start and hard to settle. Rooms divide along lines nobody predicts, and someone always asks what they would have done. Choose this Swedish original over the 2020 American remake, Downhill, which plays the material as broader comedy.
More about Force Majeure4
Gone Baby Gone (2007)
7.6/10on IMDb
Released
Ben Affleck's directing debut, adapted from Dennis Lehane's novel, begins as a missing-child case in Boston's Dorchester and builds to one of the hardest choices in modern American crime cinema. Without giving it away, the film asks whether doing what the law requires and doing what is best for a child can be two different things, and how far you would bend for either. Amy Ryan's Oscar-nominated turn as the girl's mother makes the dilemma impossible to judge from a comfortable distance.
More about Gone Baby Gone5
Do the Right Thing (1989)
7.9/10on IMDb
Released
Spike Lee wrote, directed and plays Mookie, the delivery man at Sal's pizzeria in Bedford-Stuyvesant, and the film still puts its title question to every audience that sees it. Over one hot summer day, small grievances about respect, ownership and policing build toward a decision people have argued about ever since. Lee gives Sal, Mookie and the whole block enough humanity that nobody in the room can settle the argument by picking a villain, which is exactly what makes the discussion afterward so productive.
More about Do the Right Thing6
Eye in the Sky (2015)
7.3/10on IMDb
Released
A drone strike on militants in a Nairobi safe house is ready to go, until a young girl sets up near the target to sell her mother's bread. Gavin Hood's thriller then becomes a real-time seminar on risk, law and political cover, as Helen Mirren's colonel pushes for the strike and officials keep passing the decision up the chain. It works brilliantly for a group because the trade-off is stated so plainly: how much danger to one child is acceptable to stop a probable bombing? It was also Alan Rickman's last live-action film.
More about Eye in the Sky7
The Hunt (2012)
8.3/10on IMDb
Released
Mads Mikkelsen won Best Actor at Cannes as Lucas, a divorced kindergarten teacher whose small Danish community turns on him after a false accusation. Because the audience knows he is innocent, the debate moves somewhere more uncomfortable: what should his neighbors have done with what they believed, and how can a community protect children without destroying an innocent man? Thomas Vinterberg's drama is painful to sit through, but its questions about belief, evidence and mob certainty are exactly the kind a club can work through together.
More about The Hunt8
Doubt (2008)
7.5/10on IMDb
Released
At a Bronx Catholic school in 1964, a strict principal becomes convinced that a popular priest has behaved improperly with a student, and she has no proof. John Patrick Shanley adapted his own play, and Meryl Streep, Philip Seymour Hoffman, Amy Adams and Viola Davis all earned Oscar nominations. The film is built to split a room on how much certainty you need before acting on a suspicion, and whether doubt is a virtue or an excuse. Viola Davis's single scene, as the boy's mother, is the one most groups end up arguing about.
More about Doubt9
A Separation (2011)
8.3/10on IMDb
Released
Asghar Farhadi's drama starts with a couple at a stalemate: Simin wants to leave Iran with their daughter, and Nader will not abandon his father, who has Alzheimer's. The caregiver he hires, a devout woman from a poor suburb, brings a second family into the story, and a confrontation between the two households ends up in court. Every adult has a decent reason and something left unsaid, so a group spends the evening sorting out who lied, which lies were forgivable, and whether class and faith change what honesty demands. It was the first Iranian film to win the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film and the Golden Bear at Berlin, and it grips like a thriller.
More about A Separation10
Dead Man Walking (1995)
7.5/10on IMDb
Released
Tim Robbins adapted Sister Helen Prejean's book about her spiritual work with a man on death row, and the film's great strength is that it argues with itself. Sean Penn's Matthew Poncelet is neither easy to pity nor simple to condemn, and the victims' parents are given real weight rather than a token scene. Susan Sarandon won the Oscar for Best Actress as Prejean. Groups that agree about capital punishment before the screening often find their certainty tested by the end of it.
More about Dead Man Walking11
Women Talking (2022)
6.9/10on IMDb
Released
Sarah Polley's Oscar-winning adaptation of Miriam Toews's novel is a debate on screen: after a series of assaults, the women of an isolated religious colony must decide whether to stay and do nothing, stay and fight, or leave. The film lays out each position with such care that a club can carry the argument on in its own voices, weighing forgiveness, faith, safety and what is owed to children. It is quiet and talk-heavy by design, which is precisely what makes it so valuable for a discussion night.
More about Women Talking12
Parasite (2019)
8.5/10on IMDb
Released
Bong Joon Ho's story of a poor family working its way into a rich household is gripping as a thriller, and it hands a club a genuinely contested question: who, if anyone, is the parasite? Sympathies shift scene by scene between the Kims and the Parks, and groups rarely agree on where they should land, or on how much the film blames people rather than the system around them. It won the Palme d'Or and became the first non-English-language film to win the Oscar for Best Picture, so it is an easy sell to a mixed room.
More about Parasite13
The Truman Show (1998)
8.2/10on IMDb
Released
Peter Weir's comedy about a man whose entire life is a television show, legally adopted as a baby by the studio that films him, grows sharper with every year of reality TV and social media. Jim Carrey makes Truman easy to love, which leaves the real argument to Ed Harris's Christof: is he a monster, or a producer giving viewers exactly what they keep tuning in for? A good pick for a mixed group, because it plays as pure entertainment and still leaves everyone in the audience implicated.
More about The Truman Show14
Gattaca (1997)
7.7/10on IMDb
Released
Andrew Niccol's elegant science fiction imagines a society that sorts people by their genes, with Ethan Hawke as a man conceived outside the genetic selection program who borrows the identity of a "valid" played by Jude Law. The question has only become more practical since 1997: if parents could choose their children's traits, should they, and is discrimination by DNA different from other kinds? It is a handsome, easy watch for a group that wants a big idea without heavy going.
More about Gattaca15
Ex Machina (2015)
7.7/10on IMDb
Released
Alex Garland's directing debut sends a young programmer to a remote house to run a Turing test on a humanoid robot built by his reclusive boss. The conversation afterward splits on questions that are no longer hypothetical: what would count as a mind, who is manipulating whom, and what is owed to something that might be conscious. Alicia Vikander's performance keeps the answer just out of reach, and Oscar Isaac's swaggering tech founder gives the room someone else to argue about.
More about Ex Machina16
Another Round (2020)
7.7/10on IMDb
Released
Four jaded teachers test a theory that people are born with a blood alcohol deficiency of 0.05 percent, and for a while their lessons and lives seem to improve. Thomas Vinterberg's Oscar winner refuses to be either a cautionary tale or a drinking ad, which is why groups split on it: is it a celebration of letting go, a portrait of midlife despair, or both at once? Mads Mikkelsen, by turns sheepish and exhilarated, makes it very hard to treat any of these men simply as a warning.
More about Another Round17
The Banshees of Inisherin (2022)
7.6/10on IMDb
Released
On an island off the west coast of Ireland in 1923, with the civil war going on across the water, Colm simply decides he no longer wants to be friends with Pádraic. Martin McDonagh's tragicomedy turns that small decision into a big debate: does Colm have the right to spend his remaining years on something he thinks will last, rather than on a kind but dull companion, and how much does niceness count next to ambition? Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson make both sides persuasive, and a room tends to split cleanly down the middle.
More about The Banshees of Inisherin18
Promising Young Woman (2020)
7.5/10on IMDb
Released
Emerald Fennell's debut, which won the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay, follows Carey Mulligan's Cassie as she fakes drunkenness to confront men who prey on drunk women. It is darkly funny and deliberately provocative, and its reception was polarized, with critics arguing over its tone, its ending and its feminist credentials. That is exactly why it works for a club. Expect strong disagreement about whether its revenge story is cathartic, reckless or a challenge aimed at the audience, and note that sexual assault sits at its center.
More about Promising Young Woman19
TÁR (2022)
7.4/10on IMDb
Released
Cate Blanchett's Lydia Tár is a world-famous conductor in charge of a Berlin orchestra when accusations of misconduct begin to close in. Todd Field never hands the audience the full file, so the arguments run toward power, mentorship and whether a great artist can be separated from her conduct. Critics themselves split on whether it takes aim at so-called cancel culture or examines it squarely, which tells you how lively your own discussion will be. At 158 minutes it is demanding, but Blanchett holds every scene.
More about TÁR20
Marriage Story (2019)
7.9/10on IMDb
Released
Noah Baumbach's portrait of a bicoastal divorce is the film most likely to split a room by who you came with. Scarlett Johansson and Adam Driver make both spouses sympathetic and both at fault, and the lawyers, including Laura Dern in an Oscar-winning turn, show how a legal process can push decent people toward their worst selves. Ask the group whose side they were on halfway through, then again at the end, and compare the answers.
More about Marriage Story21
Thank You for Smoking (2005)
7.5/10on IMDb
Released
For a lighter evening, Jason Reitman's satire follows Aaron Eckhart's Nick Naylor, chief spokesman for Big Tobacco, as he tries to remain a role model for his 12-year-old son. The film is funny enough to win over the skeptics in the room, but it plants a real question: is a brilliant argument for a harmful product just free speech and personal choice, or something worse? Most groups end up admitting, a little uncomfortably, how often Nick wins the argument.
More about Thank You for Smoking22
Society of the Snow (2023)
7.8/10on IMDb
Released
J. A. Bayona's account of the 1972 crash of Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571 in the Andes keeps the survivors' dignity at its center while facing head on the choice that made the story famous: whether to eat those who had died in order to stay alive. Because the film takes faith and the bonds between the survivors seriously, discussion moves past shock to what they owed one another. It is harrowing in places, with an intense crash sequence, but it is one of the most humane survival films a group could choose.
More about Society of the Snow23
Juror #2 (2024)
7.0/10on IMDb
Released
Clint Eastwood's courtroom drama gives Nicholas Hoult's juror an unbearable secret: during a murder trial, he realizes he may himself be responsible for the death. Every choice he makes afterward is a test the audience takes with him, weighing honesty against family and asking what justice requires when the truth would cost you everything. Toni Collette's ambitious prosecutor adds a second conscience to argue about. It pairs naturally with 12 Angry Men for a two-week season on juries.
More about Juror #224
It Was Just an Accident (2025)
7.4/10on IMDb
Released
Jafar Panahi's 2025 Palme d'Or winner begins when a mechanic thinks he recognizes, from the squeak of a prosthetic leg, the man who tortured him in an Iranian prison. What follows is a tense argument among former prisoners: are they sure, and if they are, what should they do with him? It turns the revenge thriller into a debate the audience joins, and its questions about certainty, justice and the risk of becoming like your captors travel well beyond Iran.
More about It Was Just an Accident
