Copyright © 2026 OyList. All Rights Reserved.
Share
Items27
22
Malted milk
Have guests stir a small amount of malted milk powder into a splash of hot cocoa before filling the mug. The paste helps avoid lumps and gives the drink a toasted, milkshake-like flavor. Check labels for milk and barley.
More about Malted milk23
Peppermint extract
Give people a dropper for this concentrated stir-in. A tiny amount will mint up a whole cup, so add it before whipped cream and taste first. Keep the bottle separate from the plain vanilla.
More about Peppermint extract24
Butterscotch
Set out a small pitcher of pourable butterscotch sauce as a stir-in. Pair it with whipped cream or use it on its own for a brown-sugar flavor. Keep the shared cocoa plain so guests can decide how sweet to make a mug.
More about Butterscotch25
Peanut butter
Whisk a small dab of smooth peanut butter into a splash of hot cocoa before filling the mug. Use a separate spoon and label the peanut add-in clearly. It makes a richer cup for guests choosing it.
More about Peanut butter26
Coconut cream
Whip a chilled portion of thick coconut cream and use a little dollop on top. It’s a useful dairy-free topping when the cocoa base is dairy-free too. Keep its serving spoon separate from the dairy whipped cream.
More about Coconut cream27
Poblano
Use a small pinch of ground ancho, which comes from dried poblanos, for a softly fruity, smoky heat. Stir it into an individual mug and taste before adding more. Cinnamon goes with it if someone wants a spicier cup.
More about Poblano